The Unresolved Contrast Between the Philosophical History and Political History of India
In this series
Because K.M. Munshi lived this Sanatana value system, he gave us a highly accurate perspective to understand not just the history but the psyche and forces that defined and shaped the dark period of Muslim rule. This perspective tells us that the epochal year of 1000 CE marks the end of ancient India and birthed medieval India, an era that can be correctly called the Muslim period. Munshi describes the finale of the trajectory of this period in memorable phraseology.
When was the last time you read the phrase, “period of collective resistance” in any mainstream work of Indian history? Indeed, R.C. Majumdar echoes Munshi when he describes this period more bluntly: he calls it as the period during which India first lost her freedom to an alien imperialism disguised as a religion.
I call it as the Age of Hindu Enslavement in their own homeland.
Among the most notable insights that Munshi provides about the Age of Resistance is the enduring legacy of the indomitable Mihira Bhoja of Kanauj. We’re stunned with admiration when we learn the fact that Mihira Bhoja seeded a tightly-knit confederacy of various clans of Gujarat and Rajasthan into an “invulnerable hierarchy.” This hierarchy would outlast him for over a thousand years and its several branches became the powerful Rajput kingdoms of Rajasthan. Here is the glimpse Munshi gives:
This genius-level of political and military organization is unparalleled anywhere in the world and its story has still not been told in the truthful manner it merits. And only people like Munshi could detect this unbroken continuity for such a prolonged period because they were rooted in the cultural and civilisational fount that gave rise to it.
Facets of the Age of Resistance
Tracing the origins of the Age of Resistance to Mahmud Ghazni’s barbaric, Islam-fuelled invasions up to the rise of the Khaljis, Munshi correctly says that this period has not been studied from India’s point of view which includes the “trials she passed through; of the sufferings she underwent when foreign elements forced their way into her life-blood…how she reacted to the situation…of the ways in which she reconstructed, achieved and fulfilled herself.” As we note the pathetic state of history-writing even today, barring few exceptional works written by devoted scholars and writers, this story remains largely untold.
Even more brilliantly, this is how Munshi encapsulates the full truth of the Age of Resistance or the Muslim period:
The permanent destruction of ancient India after 1000 CE occurred solely because of the fundamental creed of the alien religion that invaded it. Earlier foreign invaders like the Greeks, Kushanas, Sakas and Hunas were comprehensively expelled but those who stayed back were seamlessly absorbed into the soothing and accommodating currents of the Sanatana river. This happened because in Munshi’s words, “the vitality of the culture and social organization found it easy to absorb most of these alien elements.” Thus,
The term Aryavarata consciousness is a highly original coinage of K.M. Munshi about which we have written in detail in a separate essay. Indeed, every major Hindu political resurgence during the Age of Resistance is themed by the invisible but subconsciously present Aryavarata Consciousness—from the grand Vijayanagara Empire to the founding of the Sikh Pantha to Shivaji, the Maratha Empire and Maharaja Ranjit Singh. India has risen each time Sanatana Dharma has resurged.
The lesser-known aspects on the Hindu side during this Age of Resistance are truly eye-opening.
Munshi’s analysis is pure gold and at once shatters the infinite myths of a timeless Hindu-Muslim unity and an alleged syncretic culture. Indeed, few things have damaged the Hindu psyche as much as this colossal myth of syncretic culture, a myth created by weak-kneed Hindus of the late eighteenth century which reached several Gandhian climaxes later.
On a much more mundane plane, this is yet another reality of the myth. Throughout the Age of Resistance,
The History of the Dharmasastras
The history of our Dharmasastras is another parallel track that has almost a one-to-one correspondence to the political and economic history of the Age of Resistance. As Munshi observes, the Hindus of this period tried to
And today we have a substantial number of young Hindu women who jeer these heroic women by reducing them only to their vaginas. This depraved mindset is the direct creation of the “education” system of “independent” India.
The Role of Sanyasis and Acharyas
The treatment of the history of the Age of Resistance will remain incomplete without narrating the stellar and central role that our Acharyas, Swamis, Bairagis, Yogis, and bards played in keeping the Sanatana flame burning at a profound level. It was a decentralized national network of spiritual resistance which aided the swords of the millions of patriots waiting to overthrow the hated Turushka. This spiritual resistance, like the Sanatana-Ganga, was a perennial flow. Its most recent eruption was the incredible Sanyasi Andolan that lasted a full fifty years from 1770-1820 against the East India Company. The Sanyasi Andolan inspired Bankim Chandra Chattopadhyaya to write his masterpiece, Anandmath, a crown-jewel of Indian and Bengali literature. K.M. Munshi poignantly describes these Sanyasis in the Age of Resistance:
From this emerges another important factor of Indian history that has largely been overlooked if not wholly ignored. Indeed, it is quite amazing that the history of Indian philosophy, spirituality, sects, and schools have largely been preserved intact without distortions. This history presents a continuous and cohesive narrative from the Vedic era up to the present but the political history of India is a quagmire of distortions, rampant whitewashing and patent falsehoods. Munshi’s words in this regard will remain relevant until this situation is resolved with truth, determination and perseverance as our guides.
This completes our discussion on K.M. Munshi’s magnificent vision for writing the full history of India. He realized the vision in the form of the majestic eleven volumes of The History and Culture of the Indian People published by Bharatiya Vidya Bhavan, another enduring institution he founded.
The story of how these volumes were written will be narrated in the next and concluding part of this series.
To be continued
The Dharma Dispatch is now available on Telegram! For original and insightful narratives on Indian Culture and History, subscribe to us on Telegram.