The Western Encroachment of the Hindu Spiritual Civilisation: Pramatha Nath Bose's Verdict

In the concluding episode of this series, Pramatha Nath Bose invokes the appalling consequences of the erosion of the Hindu spiritual civilisation by inroads made into it by Western materialism.
The Western Encroachment of the Hindu Spiritual Civilisation: Pramatha Nath Bose's Verdict

In this Series:

The Western Encroachment of the Hindu Spiritual Civilisation: Pramatha Nath Bose's Verdict
How Western Materialism Erodes Hindu Ethics: An Early Caution by Pramatha Nath Bose
The Western Encroachment of the Hindu Spiritual Civilisation: Pramatha Nath Bose's Verdict
Pramatha Nath Bose's Brilliant Contrast of the Animalistic West and the Spiritual Hindu Civilisation

UNDER WESTERN INFLUENCE, those of our countrymen who can afford it are doing their utmost to emulate Europe in their desire for material gratification and complicity of living. In the West, the perpetual rise in the standard of luxuries and sensual enjoyments has been attended by evil consequences of a serious character. But from the point of view of mere material progress, there has been a certain amount of good also. The multiplication of wants in the West has been partly the cause and partly the outcome of the immense accumulation of wealth and of the remarkable progress in mechanical invention.

In India, the spread of western luxuries without the previous accumulation of wealth or the preparation of mechanical talent and the development of industrial qualities cannot imply progress of any description. On the contrary, it connotes considerable degeneration. It is the spiritual and the ethical faculties which differentiate man from the lower animals and since our civilization attained its highest stage, the inner life has been more thought of than the outer, and spiritual and ethical development has been accorded a higher place than material progress. The West is just beginning to see this, and the latest Western philosophy is an echo of the Indian. The expansion of animal life which we are gaining is poor compensation for the contraction of the ethical and spiritual life from which we are suffering. The adoption of the Western materialist ideal by the Hindus is rather a climb-down than a lift up for them.

Some of our reformers are doing their very best to bring our society into line with the West. Any custom or practice which does not meet with Western approval is condemned and abandoned by them. They are endeavouring to cast Hindu Society into Western mould and to reform it past recognition. I would ask them to ponder whether the goal they are after would be conducive to the maintenance of the life of our civilization. As I am writing this, I have before me a description of the moral condition of one of the centres of Western civilisation:

The general deterioration of public morals may be traced to the night life of the German capital. The decline in the German birth rate, so distressing to German patriots, is also regarded as one of the results of the unrestrained nightly dissipation. One means suggested by the Germans to increase the birth rate is based upon their inordinate love of titles. Startling statistics were recently given regarding the increase in divorces, especially in Berlin, which apparently is Germany’s Reno. If the present increase in divorces continues, in 1957 there will be no married persons who have not at some time been divorced except those who have just wedded. There are 150,000 children mostly under three years of age orphaned by their parents’ divorce, and at the present rate of increase will reach half a million within a few years. The growth of luxury, increasing immorality and night life are claimed as the principal contributing causes especially in Berlin. One weekly paper says there is a small Prussian town where it would be difficult to find one young married woman who is faithful to her husband. Many of the night resorts in Berlin do not open their doors until 2’O clock in the morning, and several open after the cabarets and dance balls are closed and continue till daylight. To see men in evening dress returning home at 8 and 6 ‘O clock in the morning is not unusual.

This description recalls the condition of Rome before her downfall, when one Emperor “gave rewards to women who had many children, prohibited those who were under forty-five years of age and who had no children, from wearing jewels and riding in litters. Another: “ in view of the general avoidance of legal marriage and resort to concubinage with slaves was compelled to impose penalties upon the unmarried, when to be childless and therefore without the natural restraint of a family, was looked down upon as a singular felicity.”

The Western Encroachment of the Hindu Spiritual Civilisation: Pramatha Nath Bose's Verdict
The Notre Dame Fire and the Hindu Civilisational Resilience: Europe on the Brink

We are unquestionably getting a broader outlook on life, but we should inquire whether it is not shallower than of yore. We are imbibing the modern idea of the Rights of Man, but we should ponder whether we are not at the same time, losing sight of the ancient idea of the Duties of Man. We are learning to take a brighter view of mundane life than the ancient philosophers, but we should consider whether much of the brightness is not the glamour of flimsy tinsel.

A Chinese philosopher, Lao Tzu, sums up all human virtues under three heads—benevolence, humility and economy (simplicity of living). Our Rishis and sages also have always emphasised the importance of these virtues.

As we have seen above, the influence of the Western environment is tending to weaken them seriously, if not to destroy them, and thereby jeopardise the harmony of Hindu civilisation. The preservation of its life depends upon the restoration of that harmony, which cannot be effected unless we resist the insidious encroachment of modern materialism and go back to our ancient ethical and spiritual ideals.

Series concluded

The Dharma Dispatch is now available on Telegram! For original and insightful narratives on Indian Culture and History, subscribe to us on Telegram.

Related Stories

No stories found.
The Dharma Dispatch