Raghubir Sinh: The Forgotten Historian Who Challenged the Writing of Indian History

A royal scholar, the youngest disciple of Jadunath Sarkar, and the founder of a remarkable research library in Sitamau—Raghubir Sinh questioned the very foundations of India's colonial-era historical discourse in 1931.

Raghubir Sinh: The Forgotten Historian Who Challenged the Writing of Indian History
Illustrative image of Maharajkumar Raghubir Sinh

Editor’s Note

MAHARAJKUMAR SRI RAGHUBIR SINH is a name largely unknown to the general public. He was also a unique phenomenon to emerge in the twentieth century. Born in the royal lineage of the kingdom of Sitamau, Sri Raghubir Sinh declined to succeed to its throne and instead chose to devote his whole life to the pursuit of history. Not only did he become a distinguished scholar of history but built a world-class research library in Sitamau, once a capital city, now a town and nagar panchayat near Mandsaur. 

Oh! And Sri Raghubir Sinh was also the youngest and a favourite disciple of Acharya Jadunath Sarkar. The library was the fruit of years of close collaboration between the two giants. 

As a history scholar of impeccable standards, Sri Raghubir Sinh authored several seminal and path-breaking volumes in both English and Hindi. His first acclaimed work was his DLitt thesis titled Malwa in Transition: Or, A Century of Anarchy (1698–1765). 

But before he undertook serious scholarly studies, Sri Raghubir Sinh wrote a mid-sized book titled Poorva-Madhyakalin Bharat (Pre-medieval India) when he was just twenty-three. While it isn’t exactly groundbreaking, it did break ground in an important way. Published in 1931 at a time when Indian history and historiography were academically and politically under British control, the book asked a straightforward question: Are we studying the true history of India today?        

Therefore, the work assumes some importance both as an academic study and as a study of the evolution of history writing in India. This essay series provides some translated excerpts from the work, offered in a spirit of public service.

Happy reading!    

MEDIEVAL INDIAN HISTORICAL DISCOURSE

According to Leibniz, “the present was created in the past.” In other words, the questions and problems confronting the country today first originated in the distant past. Several events occurred in the past which gave rise to certain new questions. As time and circumstances changed, these questions underwent successive transformations, and today they confront us either in their original form or in some other altered form.

Therefore, in order to resolve many of the problems of the modern age, it is of paramount importance that we undertake a comprehensive study of our ancient history.

Are we, today, studying the true history of India? The history of ancient times has become so deeply submerged in the distant past and the depths of oblivion. The vicissitudes of time, political revolutions and other upheavals have so scattered and destroyed the historical material of that age, that writing a connected history of that period is difficult.

Despite having to contend with all these difficulties, those lovers of history who are today labouring strenuously to discover India's ancient and obscure past and unravel its historical riddles deserve such a debt of gratitude from the people of India that they can never be repaid for their efforts.

In spite of the incessant changes of time and the absence of historical accounts written by the Hindus, a very considerable body of material relating to the history of India's early medieval period is available to historians today. Yet, even with all this material at hand, the attention of historians has not been drawn towards this period. The sole reason for this indifference among scholars is that, according to their assessment, studying this period is unnecessary.

THE IMPORTANCE OF THE HISTORY OF EARLY MEDIEVAL INDIA

We must, however, always bear one thing in mind: no event in the history of any country, however insignificant it may appear, is entirely unworthy of consideration. The history of every country passes through periods which, viewed externally, seem ordinary and devoid of importance. Yet it is precisely during such periods that numerous tendencies and movements begin to take shape imperceptibly within society, and, with the passage of time, acquire great significance.

If we wish to obtain a complete understanding of the greatness of northern medieval India (during the Mughal period), it is absolutely essential that we acquaint ourselves with the history of early medieval India.

We are left astonished when we behold the grandeur of the Mughal period. Yet, at that moment, we forget that the foundation for this greatness was laid by those victorious warriors who entered an unfamiliar land beset with difficulties and established there their own sentiments, ideas, ideals and a new society.

It was these very warriors, who achieved the initial victories, who sowed the seeds of that new civilisation which, with the passage of time, grew and flourished, reaching its full development during the Mughal period.

It was during this early medieval period that an extraordinary synthesis took place between the materialistic ideas of the West and the spiritual thought of the East, giving rise to an entirely new civilisation. This is precisely why the civilisation of the Mughal period was so very different from the contemporary civilisations of other Muslim countries.

Donate to The Dharma Dispatch

Donate to The Dharma Dispatch

During this period, Islam and Hinduism influenced one another. On the one hand, the Bhakti movement began to emerge within Hinduism; on the other, Islam adapted itself to the requirements of its new geographical and historical setting.

Indian Islam had become so different from the Islam of its earliest days that, had the contemporary Islamic scholars of Baghdad and Cairo been called upon to examine it, they would scarcely have found any substantial difference between it and another religion.

It was during this very period that the emergence and development of India's modern languages began.

The early medieval period of Indian history, therefore, was undoubtedly a period of transition.

To regard the study of this period as unnecessary and insignificant, and consequently to pay no attention to it, while attaching greater importance to the history of the Mughal period, is unbecoming of a true historian.

Almost every historian holds the opinion that a true history of medieval India cannot be written. In the preface to his famous work Medieval India, Lane-Poole writes:

The history of Muslim-period India is a picture of the contemporary emperors, their royal courts and their wars. It contains no account of the development or decline of national (or racial) life.

Not only historians, but every reader of Indian history, would agree with this statement of Lane-Poole. Whenever a reader picks up any book to acquire knowledge of medieval Indian history, he finds that, in every work, there is little beyond descriptions of the emperors of the Delhi Sultanate and the rulers of the small kingdoms established here and there from time to time. From Elphinstone to Ishwari Prasad, all historians have followed this particular method of historical writing.

To be continued

RELATED READING

Count de Modave's India: Mughal Decline, Bengal's Wealth and the Rise of British Colonialism

Count de Modave's India: Mughal Decline, Bengal's Wealth and the Rise of British Colonialism

—
Viscount Valentia at Shivala Palace, 1803: The Tattered  Mughal House in Varanasi

Viscount Valentia at Shivala Palace, 1803: The Tattered Mughal House in Varanasi

—
Merchants of Muscat: How Hindu Traders Dominated Oman’s Economy for Centuries

Merchants of Muscat: How Hindu Traders Dominated Oman’s Economy for Centuries

—
When the Sahib Hated Holi: Viscount Valentia’s 1803 Varanasi Journal

When the Sahib Hated Holi: Viscount Valentia’s 1803 Varanasi Journal

—
The Battle of Buxar Through British Eyes: Lord Valentia’s 1803 Bihar Travelogue

The Battle of Buxar Through British Eyes: Lord Valentia’s 1803 Bihar Travelogue

—
From Pushpapura to an Opium Cantonment: Valentia’s Day in Bankipur

From Pushpapura to an Opium Cantonment: Valentia’s Day in Bankipur

—